by Dave Miller
Most residency candidates walk into their interviews focused on one thing: getting a yes. They prepare answers, polish their story, and hope the church likes them.
But a residency isn't just a job offer. It's a season that will shape how you begin to lead. The church you choose will teach you how to handle conflict, how to care for your soul, and what healthy leadership looks like, whether they mean to or not.
That's why the best candidates interview the church just as carefully as the church interviews them. Here are the questions I'd want every resident to ask before saying yes.
Five areas to ask about
1. Why does this residency exist?
A church that can clearly explain why it runs a residency has usually thought hard about what it's building.
Ask: Why does this church run a residency, and what problem is it solving for you? What does a successful resident look like at the end? And then ask the most revealing question of all: Where are your past residents now?
2. How will I actually be developed?
There’s a big difference in getting a job and being developed.
Ask: Who will supervise me, and how often will we meet? Is there a written development plan? How will I get feedback? Listen for specifics. "We'll figure it out as we go" is a yellow flag.
Also ask whether you'll see the parts of ministry most people never do: budgets, staffing decisions, elder meetings.
3. WhAT IS IT LIKE TO WORK HERE?
Every church presents its best self in an interview. Your job is to see past it.
Ask: How would staff describe the culture when the senior pastor isn't in the room? How does the team handle disagreement? What has staff turnover looked like? Using single words…what’s it like to be here Monday through Thursday? And always ask to talk with a current or former resident without leadership present.
4. What are the expectations?
Clarity now prevents resentment later. Ask about compensation, housing, benefits, hours, time off, and whether you'll need to raise support or work a second job.
One question candidates rarely ask but should: What happens if the fit isn't right partway through? A healthy church will have a thoughtful answer.
5. What happens when it ends?
If a role might be waiting at the end, find out what would need to be true for you to be offered it.
In 18 months you are so glad you hired me and I’ve been here…why?
How to ask well
You don't need to fire off every question in your first call. Spread them across the process. Purpose and development questions fit early conversations. Culture questions land better once there's some trust. Logistics and future questions belong before any offer is accepted.
Pay attention to how the church responds, not just what it says. Do they lean in, or do they get defensive? Do they answer with specifics, or with vision language? A church that welcomes hard questions now will likely welcome your growth later.
A final gut check
If a church can't clearly answer why its residency exists, it may be more about filling a staffing gap than developing a leader. That doesn't make it a bad church. It just might not be the right residency.
You're not looking for a perfect church. You're looking for one that knows what it's doing with you, and why.
If you're a church leader reading this, ask yourself how you'd answer these questions today. Your best candidates are already asking them.